The concept of the alpha male has been debated for decades—some women swear by them, others run for the hills. Sure, he’s the kind of guy who’s powerful, dominant, and turns heads when he walks into a room. But in today’s world, where women like yourself are more independent and self-sufficient than ever, does the old-school alpha male still have the same appeal?
We spoke to our readers to see what they think of alpha males, why some can’t resist them, and why others see them as a giant red flag.
Story Stages
Why Women Love Alpha Males
Despite where they might stand on the subject, most women can admit that powerful, dominant men have always had a certain pull. This is, after all, a guy who’s confident, leads without hesitation and just seems to know what he’s doing—in the boardroom, the bedroom, and everywhere in between.
Here’s why some women love alpha males:
1. Confidence is a Massive Turn-On
There’s no arguing that confidence is pretty damn sexy. An alpha male knows who he is, what he wants, and how to get it. He doesn’t second-guess himself or ask for permission—he takes charge. It’s this kind of confidence that makes a man instantly more desirable.
But of course, there’s a fine line between being genuinely self-assured and just faking it. Women can spot insecurity dressed up as arrogance from a mile away.
“A guy who walks into a room like he owns it, who’s decisive, and makes you feel like nothing could ever possibly harm you? Yeah, that’s pretty attractive in my eyes. But if he’s loud, bragging, and trying too hard? That’s not so attractive.” — Sophie, 31
2. Women Love Leaders, Not Followers
Alpha males tend to be natural leaders. Women don’t want to be with a man who waits for things to happen—they want someone who makes things happen… they want a natural leader.
Whether it’s planning a date without the dreaded “I don’t know, what do you wanna do?” back-and-forth or having the ability to handle problems without spiralling into stress, a man who can lead with confidence is incredibly attractive.
“I love a man who just takes the reins. If I’m dating someone, I don’t want to plan every single thing—we don’t need to flip a coin over dinner reservations. Just tell me we’re going somewhere amazing, book the table, and let me enjoy the night. That’s what a man should do.” — Jasmine, 28
3. The Bad Boy Appeal
Let’s be real—alpha males have that bad-boy charm that makes them damn near irresistible. The swagger, the confidence, the way they look at you like they know exactly what they’re doing… it’s no surprise women find them intoxicating.
There’s just something about a man who’s a little unpredictable, a little untamed—that thrill of knowing you’re playing with fire, but loving the burn.
“I hate admitting this, but I’ve always been drawn to cocky guys. Not total assholes, but the ones who know they’re sexy and don’t apologize for it. It’s frustrating and hot at the same time.” — Emma, 27
Why Some Women Think Alpha Males Are Toxic
For every woman swooning over a dominant, confident man, there’s another rolling her eyes. Some love the alpha male energy, but others? It’s a clear sign of toxicity.
Here’s why some women can’t stand them:
1. Confidence Can Easily Turn into Arrogance
There’s a fine line between sexy self-assurance and outright narcissism—and some alpha males jump right over it.
A man who’s in control? Attractive. A man who treats every interaction like an opportunity to talk about how amazing he is? Painful.
“I went on a date with this guy who called himself an ‘alpha male.’ He spent the whole night going on about how ‘women love powerful men’ and how ‘guys like him don’t settle.’ I ordered another drink just so I wouldn’t have to hear him talk anymore.” — Natasha, 29
2. They Can Be Emotionally Unavailable
Some women love a mysterious man. Others just want someone who doesn’t treat emotions like a weakness.
Many alpha males aren’t exactly known for their vulnerability. They’re too busy winning, conquering, and staying in control to get real about their feelings. For some women, that’s intriguing. For others, it’s exhausting.
“I dated an ‘alpha’ for two years. He was charming, confident, great in bed… but emotionally? A brick wall. Everything was about his success, his status, his next big move. I just wanted a real connection. After a while, it felt like I was dating a brand, not a person.” — Mia, 34
3. Control Can Quickly Become Manipulation
There’s a fine line between a man who takes charge and a man who takes over. Confidence? Sexy. Decisiveness? Hot. But when a guy starts dictating what you wear, who you see, or how you live? That’s not dominance—it’s control.
“There’s a difference between a strong man and a controlling man. One makes you feel protected, the other makes you feel trapped.” — Olivia, 30
So, Do Women Prefer Alpha Males?
To get a little more perspective, we reached out to One Park Lane Models and spoke to Tara, one of their top London escorts, who has met more so-called “alpha males” than she can count.
“The real ‘alphas’ don’t call themselves alphas. They just take the lead, make a woman feel safe, and bring out her best. The ones who brag about being dominant? They’re usually overcompensating. Real power doesn’t need to be announced.” — Tara
That pretty much says it all. True dominance is effortless. If a man has to constantly remind you he’s an alpha, he’s probably not one.
So, what’s the verdict? Most women love confidence, strength, and leadership—but not when it comes at the cost of emotional intelligence.
Alpha males are attractive when they show self-assurance, drive, and charisma. However, they lose their appeal when that confidence morphs into arrogance, emotional detachment, or controlling behaviour. The ideal man? Someone who takes the lead but also knows when to listen, connect, and let his partner shine.
How to Be the Right Kind of Alpha
For the men reading this—if you want to embody the best traits of an alpha male (without turning into a walking red flag), here’s your blueprint:
- Confidence, not arrogance – Know your worth, but don’t feel the need to remind everyone every five minutes.
- Leadership, not control – Take charge, but respect her autonomy.
- Strength, but also vulnerability – Being emotionally available makes you powerful, not weak.
- Passion, not possession – Women want to feel desired, not owned.
So, does being an “alpha male” get you the girl? It depends. Get it right, and you’ll be irresistible. Get it wrong, and you’ll just be another guy trying way too hard.
What’s your experience with alpha males? Love them or hate them? Drop a comment below and let’s talk.
